Review Data Insights: The Top 10 Toy Stores in the US

These 10 top-rated toy stores in the US reveal how customer review data helps estimate revenue for private company targets.
Consumer
Data
North America
Review Data Insights: The Top 10 Toy Stores in the US

The holiday season is upon us and consumers are doing some heavy-duty shopping. Those who want to avoid buying toys for their little ones from big-box stores or online giants are turning to customer reviews to find the best local shops.

But review data doesn’t only matter to customers — it can also help middle market dealmakers generate revenue estimates.

The number and quality of online reviews can indicate market leadership and the size of the customer base, leading to revenue. This is especially useful for companies that have a smaller online presence, like local toy stores.

Below, we used Grata review data to compile a list of the 10 highest-rated privately owned toy stores in the US. These companies sell a variety of toys, games, and collectibles, and they have all earned 4.6 stars and above for their services.

Grata users can see more US-based privately owned toy stores with average ratings of 4 stars and above here.

Mockingbird Lane Toys and Collectibles

Location: Lawrence, KS

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 5 stars

Number of reviews: 327

Mockingbird Lane Toys and Collectibles is a retail store offering a wide range of modern and vintage toy collectibles, including G.I. Joe, Transformers, DC, Marvel, horror-themed items, and more. 

Chubzzy Wubzzy

Location: New Jersey

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 5 stars

Number of reviews: 221

Chubzzy Wubzzy Toys & Collectibles is a family-owned and operated retail shop that sells a wide range of toys and collectible products, both old and new. 

Radar Toys

Location: Eugene, OR

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 905

Radar Toys is a specialty retailer that offers a wide range of toys, collectibles, and pop culture merchandise. Its product offerings include POP figures, mystery toys, plush figures, model kits, and various collectible figures from popular franchises such as DC Comics, Disney, Marvel, and Star Wars. 

Nakama Toys

Location: Chicago, IL

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 350

Nakama Toys is a retail company that offers a wide range of collectible toys, action figures, model kits, and scale statues.

All Time Toys

Location: Sykesville, MD

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 161

All Time Toys is a retail company that specializes in selling toys, games, and pop culture collectibles. 

Funky Monkey Toys

Location: Oxford, MI

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 120

Funky Monkey Toys is a retail store that offers a wide range of toys and games for children of all ages. 

Kawaii Gifts

Location: Pittsburgh, PA

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.7 stars

Number of reviews: 269

Kawaii Gifts is a retailer that specializes in offering a wide range of cute and kawaii-themed products, including stationery, plush toys, apparel, accessories, K-Pop merchandise, and more.

Tiddlywinks Toys and Games

Location: Orange, CA

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.7 stars

Number of reviews: 106

Tiddlywinks Toys and Games is a retailer that offers a wide range of toys and games for children of all ages. 

Brad’s Toys

Location: Henderson, NV

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.6 stars

Number of reviews: 845

Brad's Toys is a retail company that offers a wide range of toys, collectibles, and related accessories such as Funko Pops, action figures, comic books, and other pop culture merchandise.

Holocron

Location: Fort Worth, TX

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.6 stars

Number of reviews: 684

Holocron Toy Store is a retail store that specializes in offering a wide range of Star Wars themed toys and collectibles.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Monthly tactics from Grata’s team and operators.

Related
Articles

From market trends to career advice, Grata’s content fuels smarter decisions.

The New Deal Team: How AI Is Changing Every Role in M&A
AI & Automation

The New Deal Team: How AI Is Changing Every Role in M&A

AI is reshaping every role on the M&A deal team — from analyst to partner. Here's what that means for the firms building for the next generation of dealmaking.
Early Deal Intelligence: The New Private Market Competitive Advantage
Business Development
Data/Analytics

Early Deal Intelligence: The New Private Market Competitive Advantage

What is early deal intelligence? Learn how Grata's Seller Intent flags companies preparing to sell, 6-12 months before a formal process begins.
Hidden Gems: Actionable, Undiscovered Opportunities in the HVAC Industry
Industrials
Data/Analytics

Hidden Gems: Actionable, Undiscovered Opportunities in the HVAC Industry

Discover 79 undiscovered HVAC companies with high Seller Intent scores. See ownership, geographic, and sector breakdowns from Grata's proprietary private market data.
Grata Expands Global Intelligence Platform with Integrated Valu8 Data, MCP Launch, and Customers in 26 Countries
UK & Ireland
Acquisition
DACH

Grata Expands Global Intelligence Platform with Integrated Valu8 Data, MCP Launch, and Customers in 26 Countries

Platform surpasses 23 million companies and 1 million transaction events following successful Valu8 integration
The PE Playbook: HVAC
Industrials
Private Equity
Market Trends

The PE Playbook: HVAC

Discover the top HVAC trends for middle market dealmakers - fragmentation, consolidation, growth areas, and recent acquisitions shaping the sector.
How Dealmakers Win Now That AI Is Table Stakes
AI & Automation

How Dealmakers Win Now That AI Is Table Stakes

New research from Financial Times Longitude and Datasite shows AI is becoming standard across M&A workflows. Learn why the next competitive advantage won't be the technology itself — but the quality of the private-market intelligence powering it.
Supercharge Your Spreadsheets by Connecting Grata's Excel Add-In to the Grata MCP
AI & Automation

Supercharge Your Spreadsheets by Connecting Grata's Excel Add-In to the Grata MCP

Learn how combining Grata's Excel Add-In with the Grata MCP makes M&A workflows more efficient and allows dealmakers to leave behind legacy tools.
Blue backgound