Review Data Insights: The Top 10 Toy Stores in the US

These 10 top-rated toy stores in the US reveal how customer review data helps estimate revenue for private company targets.
Consumer
Data
North America
Review Data Insights: The Top 10 Toy Stores in the US

The holiday season is upon us and consumers are doing some heavy-duty shopping. Those who want to avoid buying toys for their little ones from big-box stores or online giants are turning to customer reviews to find the best local shops.

But review data doesn’t only matter to customers — it can also help middle market dealmakers generate revenue estimates.

The number and quality of online reviews can indicate market leadership and the size of the customer base, leading to revenue. This is especially useful for companies that have a smaller online presence, like local toy stores.

Below, we used Grata review data to compile a list of the 10 highest-rated privately owned toy stores in the US. These companies sell a variety of toys, games, and collectibles, and they have all earned 4.6 stars and above for their services.

Grata users can see more US-based privately owned toy stores with average ratings of 4 stars and above here.

Mockingbird Lane Toys and Collectibles

Location: Lawrence, KS

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 5 stars

Number of reviews: 327

Mockingbird Lane Toys and Collectibles is a retail store offering a wide range of modern and vintage toy collectibles, including G.I. Joe, Transformers, DC, Marvel, horror-themed items, and more. 

Chubzzy Wubzzy

Location: New Jersey

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 5 stars

Number of reviews: 221

Chubzzy Wubzzy Toys & Collectibles is a family-owned and operated retail shop that sells a wide range of toys and collectible products, both old and new. 

Radar Toys

Location: Eugene, OR

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 905

Radar Toys is a specialty retailer that offers a wide range of toys, collectibles, and pop culture merchandise. Its product offerings include POP figures, mystery toys, plush figures, model kits, and various collectible figures from popular franchises such as DC Comics, Disney, Marvel, and Star Wars. 

Nakama Toys

Location: Chicago, IL

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 350

Nakama Toys is a retail company that offers a wide range of collectible toys, action figures, model kits, and scale statues.

All Time Toys

Location: Sykesville, MD

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 161

All Time Toys is a retail company that specializes in selling toys, games, and pop culture collectibles. 

Funky Monkey Toys

Location: Oxford, MI

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.8 stars

Number of reviews: 120

Funky Monkey Toys is a retail store that offers a wide range of toys and games for children of all ages. 

Kawaii Gifts

Location: Pittsburgh, PA

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.7 stars

Number of reviews: 269

Kawaii Gifts is a retailer that specializes in offering a wide range of cute and kawaii-themed products, including stationery, plush toys, apparel, accessories, K-Pop merchandise, and more.

Tiddlywinks Toys and Games

Location: Orange, CA

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.7 stars

Number of reviews: 106

Tiddlywinks Toys and Games is a retailer that offers a wide range of toys and games for children of all ages. 

Brad’s Toys

Location: Henderson, NV

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.6 stars

Number of reviews: 845

Brad's Toys is a retail company that offers a wide range of toys, collectibles, and related accessories such as Funko Pops, action figures, comic books, and other pop culture merchandise.

Holocron

Location: Fort Worth, TX

Ownership: Bootstrapped

Average rating: 4.6 stars

Number of reviews: 684

Holocron Toy Store is a retail store that specializes in offering a wide range of Star Wars themed toys and collectibles.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Monthly tactics from Grata’s team and operators.

Related
Articles

From market trends to career advice, Grata’s content fuels smarter decisions.

Datasite Brings AI to the Entire Deal Lifecycle – from Target to Transaction
AI & Automation

Datasite Brings AI to the Entire Deal Lifecycle – from Target to Transaction

Grata Intelligence and Datasite Connect allow deal teams to use AI from opportunity discovery through diligence while retaining document-level permissions.
Introducing Grata Intelligence: A More Connected Way to Execute M&A
AI & Automation
Workflows

Introducing Grata Intelligence: A More Connected Way to Execute M&A

Meet Grata Intelligence, Datasite’s agentic M&A workspace built to help dealmakers make better-informed decisions, accelerate execution and move deals forward.
How Agentic AI Is Changing Buyer List Building
AI & Automation
Sell-Side

How Agentic AI Is Changing Buyer List Building

See how agentic AI is driving efficiency in M&A buyer list building, from testing strategies to qualifying, prioritizing, and keeping the buyer universe current.
How AI Agents Are Changing Investment Committee Preparation
AI & Automation
Buy-Side

How AI Agents Are Changing Investment Committee Preparation

Discover how AI agents are transforming investment committee preparation by streamlining research, updating IC memos, and strengthening investment analysis.
How Agentic AI Is Improving Outreach in M&A
AI & Automation
Sourcing

How Agentic AI Is Improving Outreach in M&A

Learn how agentic AI is making M&A outreach better by helping dealmakers prioritize targets, time it right, personalize messages, and build stronger relationships.
How Agentic AI Is Changing Market Research in M&A
AI & Automation
Market Trends

How Agentic AI Is Changing Market Research in M&A

See how agentic AI is transforming the market research process in M&A, from mapping markets, to enriching company data, to analyzing structure, to testing deal theses.
Introducing Grata's Private Market Index
Market Trends
Data/Analytics

Introducing Grata's Private Market Index

Private Market Index gives dealmakers an earlier view into active M&A activity so they can prioritize sectors, validate theses, and act before their competitors.
Blue backgound